Tag Archives: Foreign Material Hazard

Magnet For Metal Fragment Control

By Debby L. Newslow, Kevin Baker
No Comments

Introduction:

When considering existing and potential foreign material hazards, metal fragments are consistently identified as a concern. Depending on the situation, the potential risk (how significant the outcome) and significance (how likely it is to occur) often result in the identification of a significant hazard that must be controlled through a CCP or, at a minimum, through a prerequisite program, which may include the use of a metal detector and/or magnet strategically placed in the process. When discussing food safety and quality, foreign material-related incidents remain the most frequent hazards identified. Since these incidents usually affect a limited few, foreign material hazards do not receive the publicity that pathogenic bacterial contamination does, which can harm large numbers of consumers in each incident.

The objective must be to produce a product that is free of any metal fragment contamination. This can be accomplished through the reduction of contamination, risks, and consequences such as: controlling the hazard by eliminating or reducing it to an acceptable level using effective prerequisite programs (PRPs) or by control applied at an identified Critical Control Point; and verification that the PRP or CCP is monitored and confirmed effective through a well-defined food safety, GMP, and/or Food Safety Management System Internal Audit program.

This article provides a basic foundation for achieving success by controlling metal as a foreign material hazard. Control of metal begins with control of raw materials, achieved through effective communication with suppliers through a well-defined, implemented, and ongoing supplier management program, along with a defined program for magnet testing of ingredients and incoming raw materials. This type of program includes metal detectors and magnets designed for specific functions and locations, strategically placed in the process. It also addresses equipment verification and validation by a qualified external company, as well as verification performed and managed through an effective internal preventive maintenance program.

The magnets in the process are critical, and a magnet monitoring/testing program is implemented and maintained in a manner that is effective for the process overall. It is recommended that the final magnet’s strength be measured at 10,000 Gauss. Magnet strength must be monitored at a predefined frequency sufficient to provide confidence in the program. In addition, magnets must be cleaned and inspected for damage on a defined schedule. Findings must be evaluated to determine the source, and the source must either be corrected or eliminated.

It is recommended that the magnet’s strength be verified at least annually by a third party using a calibrated Gauss Meter. The third party must provide a record confirming traceability to an NIST or known standard to confirm its accuracy. It is also recommended that, depending on the process and product, verification using an internally owned calibrated Gauss Meter be performed internally as part of the preventive maintenance program either quarterly or semi-annually.

Depending on the nature of the product, the process may also be equipped with a well-designed metal detector and/or X-ray machine, strategically placed to evaluate the final products. It is critical that this equipment is also verified for effectiveness and accuracy by a third-party calibration service company at a predetermined frequency (minimum annually), based on the products and processes. At a minimum, a prerequisite program requires trained operators to monitor and record at a defined frequency (i.e., once every 60 minutes) using control pieces to be implemented and maintained. It is strongly recommended that a program be defined, implemented, and maintained to verify the metal detector’s effectiveness.

This article provides more detail on the actual requirements for monitoring the effectiveness of process magnets, comparing the well-known Pull Test and Gauss Meter measurements. The complementary effect of a synergistic and strategically placed magnet and metal detector in a process to monitor, control, and/or eliminate metal as a foreign material hazard is also reviewed.

The most common locations for the placement of magnets for foreign material control are:

  • Product Intakes
  • Ingredient Intakes
  • Equipment Protection – High Impact
  • Indicator Magnets
  • Final Finished Product/Packing magnets
  • Lab Magnets for testing finished products and ingredients

Potential risks and consequences of inferior magnets, which do not meet today’s standards, may include one or more of the following:

  • Product Contamination
  • Consumer Injury
  • Product Recall
  • Brand Name Risk
  • Equipment Damage/Failure – High Impact
  • Product Contamination
  • Loss of Product
  • Down Time
  • Costly Repairs
  • Ongoing Maintenance
  • Malfunctioning
  • De-Sensitization
  • Product Wastage
  • Nuisance Trips
  • Down Time

Magnet Verification:

Magnets and magnetic separators are used in the food industry worldwide to extract metal contamination from food product streams, reducing contamination risks and consequences and to satisfy PRP/CCP control and food safety audits. Magnets are often installed in the final and critical product locations as a safeguard against metal fragment contamination. Essential criteria for effective results include:

  • Strength of the magnet at 8000 – 10,000 Gauss for foreign material control
  • Strength of the magnet at 3200 – 4000 Gauss for the protection of equipment
  • Pole spacing at a maximum gap of 22mm in 1” diameter bar and grate magnets
  • Objective evidence (records) available confirming magnets are verified to an NIST or known standard at time of installation and then a minimum of annually thereafter
  • Minimum coverage at approximately 80% of the product stream
  • Sizing at maximum product contact without product blockage or hang-up
  • Cleaned at a defined frequency either manually or automatically
  • An efficiently designed retention area on the magnet to retain collections of magnetic contamination between magnet cleanings

It is necessary to develop, implement, and maintain an effective magnet verification program because magnets CAN lose strength over time and can do so very rapidly in certain use conditions. Even if a magnet appears to be extracting metal, the following questions must be asked:

  • “What is getting past the magnet?”
  • “Is the magnet sufficiently strong for the application in which it is placed?”
  • “What is the most effective means to determine the strength of the magnet and ensure that its function within the process is effective?”

The two main methods used to test the strength of magnets are the Pull Test and the Gauss Meter Test.

The Pull Test Method:

Prior to 1960, the Pull Test Method was developed to determine the relative strength of magnetic equipment. The “pull test kit” consists of a handheld scale device and a variety of test pieces. The test piece used depends on the type of magnet being tested. Although the Pull Test Method has been used for many years, the pioneers of the method stated, “’We suggest you use the kit not to verify the values”. The manual “Pull Test” method may be considered by some major auditing and standards bodies as ‘outdated method for magnet verification.’

Is the “Pull Test”- method accurate? Pull test values can and will vary. It is not uncommon for different individuals to record different results. An experienced person performing this test regularly may obtain meaningful comparisons of magnet strength over time, but, again, results often vary even when the same individual performs the test.

The “Pull Test” method was designed to put an approximate value on the holding force of a magnet or the pulling force (field depth) of a magnet (i.e., a plate magnet). It may be more appropriately called a “hold” test, as it is mainly used to compare the surface hold of one magnet with another. It is also important to note that some modern-day contaminants, such as stainless-steel fragments and magnetic stone, may be weakly magnetic. Such products ideally must “contact” the magnet surface, which makes a pull test measuring force at a distance almost irrelevant. There seems to be no specific “readings” that have been identified as a standard to determine the functionality and effectiveness.

Note that in recent years, several magnet manufacturers have developed and are now providing electronic pull-test kits for their magnets. Some state that these test kits can be used with traceability to a known NIST standard. This author does not have any experience with these. If these are used in your operation, it is recommended that you evaluate the results internally with your supplier to determine whether the readings correlate with the remaining strength and effectiveness of the magnet for the function it provides. This may be determined by evaluating with a Gauss Meter to obtain consistent results of effectiveness.

The Gauss Test Method:

The Gauss Test Method for verifying magnet strength is increasingly used in the food industry for its accuracy and ability to verify and compare strength-loss trends over time. This method uses a Gauss Meter reading taken at the magnet’s surface to provide a flux density measurement. The Gauss Meter Test Method for verifying magnet strength is increasingly used in the food industry because of its accuracy in verifying and comparing strength-loss trends over time. Gauss Meter technology is being rapidly adopted by major food companies because it provides more definitive, specific measurements. The Gauss Meter must be calibrated to an NIST or other known standard, with records (a calibration certificate) maintained to confirm its accuracy. The Gauss Meter is suitable for testing magnet strengths ranging from 1,000 to 13,000 Gauss.

The Gauss Meter is being used more frequently in the food industry over recent years because it is:

  • Definitive, Accurate, Repeatable, Calibrated
  • Surface strength of magnets is generally 10,000 Gauss now for product security in food industry
  • No safety issues with Gauss Meters
  • Gauss Meter Test conforms to current standard for final magnets in food industry
  • Modern calibrated Gauss Meters can measure all strengths accurately from 1,000 Gauss > 20,000 Gauss

In today’s world, the older manual “pull test” method approximations are declining in acceptability wherever product and brand name security is critical.

Why must magnets be verified?

Four very good reasons include:

  • Initially confirm that new, final magnets are within specified strength when purchased
  • Verify that specified strength has been maintained
  • Confirm full exposure to the product stream or flow
  • Confirm magnet is effectively controlling the hazard or potential hazard of concern

A magnet that does not cover the product stream can be useful as an “indicator” but is not a sufficient magnetic separation magnet for product security.

Magnet verifications are very important, especially at a CCP and at a final process location, to confirm that the magnet is within tolerance. A Magnet Verification Report should be provided initially by the magnet supplier and then conducted every 2 years on intakes and plant protection magnets.  Magnet verifications must also be conducted with a calibrated Gauss Meter using a defined procedure and providing a record that includes the testing results and traceability that the instrument used to test the meter has a current NIST or known standard certificate.

Most Food Safety Management System Standards and even basic HACCP criteria audits depending on their defined role in the process do require verification of magnets and metal detectors either when identified as a Critical Control Point or as a Prerequisite Program.

It is recommended that magnets be verified with a calibrated Gauss meter at least once every 12 months. An effective magnet program should include an annual evaluation with a qualified third party. A verification report should be provided that:

  • Confirms individual magnets meet current standards
  • Confirms whether individual magnets are still as effective as when first installed
  • Provides the estimated coverage and magnetic strength for each magnet
  • Identifies potential risks of metal contamination
  • Provides specifications to address magnet needs

Many food companies also test their magnet strengths “in house” between the annual audits. This is a good practice; if a critical magnet is exposed to demagnetizing factors or damaged, for example, it may never be within specification. Magnets must be cleaned regularly to ensure that their efficiency is maintained. A magnet can be “shorted out” by many fine magnetics which lower its separation efficiency. It is recommended that “in house” calibrated Gauss Meter Kits be obtained for testing and monitoring the effectiveness of the magnets between the annual third-party evaluation.

The following is recommended:

  • Monitor magnet strength and maintain records of compliance
  • Ensure minimized pole band spacing related to the magnets’ functions in your operation
  • Ensure and monitor (inspection and cleaning) product to magnet coverage
  • Maintain internal knowledge and access to pertinent reference information

Following are the seven “secrets” for effective metal fragment control:

1.      Magnet Strength: A minimum of 10,000 gauss
2.      Pole Spacing: Maximum gap of 22mm unless magnet bar diameter is

35 mm or greater

3.      Documentation: All magnets verified with a calibrated (confirmed accurate to a known standard) Gauss Meter at installation and then annually
4.      Magnet strength life and safety: High vacuum resinizing and use of high grade RE80TM magnet compound
5.      Coverage: Minimum coverage, approx. 80% of product stream
6.      Magnet Sizing: Maximum contact of product with the magnet without product blockage or hang-up
7.      Magnet Cleaning: Regular manual or automatic magnet cleaning