Tag Archives: GMP

5 Tips for Conducting a Successful Internal Audit

By Michael Biros
No Comments

A strong internal audit program will help drive continuous improvement, promote a food safety culture within the organization, and help improve the external audit score.

Beyond achieving compliance with the SQF program requirements, internal audits help drive continuous improvement and can facilitate a food safety culture throughout all levels of an organization. Gary Smith, Senior Technical Director at SAI Global, discusses 5 key factors to successfully conducting an internal audit.

What is the SQF Standard: Item 2.5.7 Internal Audit?

This requirement includes methods and responsibilities for scheduling and conducting internal audits to verify the effectiveness of the SQF system including facility and equipment inspections, PRPs, food safety plans, food quality plans, and regulation controls. Companies must have an internal audit schedule with scope and frequency and records of internal audits, corrections, and corrective actions. The internal audit must be conducted by staff trained in internal audit procedures and the audit results must be communicated to relevant management.

In the SQF program, a major nonconformance indicates a systematic failure where an element is failing or not existing. Some common major nonconformances include not having a schedule of internal audits, having verification and validation activities defined but not having an internal audit program, not having a facilitator for an internal audit program assigned, and having the internal audit only cover GMPs, but not the SQF system. Some of the minor nonconformances include not having an internal auditor training for the lead auditor, not defining how results are to be communicated to leadership, not taking corrective actions for internal audits, or not having records of corrective actions.

5 Keys to Success

  1. Reach out to leadership. Work with your leadership to define objectives of the internal audit program with management to facilitate management commitment. Build the internal audit program with management objectives. Remember, it’s not the QA’s program certification, it’s the entire company’s.
  2. Formalize the audit process. Set an audit schedule and keep to it. Assign an audit team with responsibilities. Use an audit checklist. Develop an audit plan. Conduct interviews during the audit. Conduct opening and closing meetings with staff.
  3. Communicate well. Regularly provide updates to leadership at routine meetings. Provide the audit plan and checklist to auditees one week prior to the audit. Take photos of good practices and nonconformances. Provide the audit results in a timely manner.
  4. Manage internal audits as its own program. Have standard operating procedures describing the responsibilities and procedures. Have the facilitator be trained as a lead auditor and appropriate training for all team members. Include as many people as possible in the audit team from all departments within the company.
  5. Use corrective action management program for all internal audit findings. Keep an internal log of all your internal nonconformances. Use root cause analysis to understand why nonconformances occur and include internal audit findings, regulatory audit findings, nonconforming products, and customer complaints in the corrective action management plan.

A strong internal audit program will help drive continuous improvement. It will help promote ownership of the entire SQF system and promote a food safety culture within the organization. Lastly, a strong internal audit program can improve the external audit score.

For more information, see this archived webinar: SQF 5 Tips for Conducting a Successful Internal Audit 

Bob Savage, President and Founder of the HACCP Consulting Group

FSQA: Creating HACCP Excellence

By Michael Biros
No Comments
Bob Savage, President and Founder of the HACCP Consulting Group

For a successful Food Safety and Quality Assurance program, there must be management commitment and measurable expectations set. Senior management has to be committed to the program. They are the foundation for everything in food safety. They have to provide resources to develop and implement the plans across different departments as well as provide for training and encourage communication, advises Robert A. Savage, President and Founder of The HACCP Consulting Group.

Sharing some lessons learned from decades of HACCP implementation experience, Savage spoke at a recent webinar on FSQA: Creating HACCP Excellence, presented by SafetyChain Software. We present excerpts below. 

A few years ago, there was a very serious Salmonella outbreak in peanut butter. It appears that company shopped around for negative salmonella results and then shipped the product. It’s a worst case scenario, but in this case, short term profitability at the expense of food safety resulted in the over 600 illnesses and a few deaths as well as the bankruptcy of the company, described Savage.

Role of GMPs in Creating and Minimizing CCPs

Without good GMPs, facilities tend to have more CCPs than necessary. There has to be a good balance between GMPs and CCPs. When companies understand the the relationship between HACCP, GMPs, and CCPs, typically the HACCP plan would not have more than 3 or 4 CCPs and everything else is covered by GMPs. 

Best practices for HACCP management must be committed from the beginning and throughout the process. GMPs should be in place prior to even beginning to revamp the HACCP plan. Multidisciplinary HACCP teams, including QC, QA, Lab, Sanitation, Product Development and Sales, experts, should contribute to the process in developing the plan. Having a multidisciplinary team helps with achieving buy-in or company-wide commitment to the plan. 

Companies have been pretty good with monitoring, but there’s still some confusion between verification and validation. Verification is a check of the checkers. When CCPs are identified and monitored, verification is making sure that the company says what it’s doing and is doing what it says. Validation asks if the company has the right CCPs and how can they prove it. 

Best Practices for Audit Prep

USDA regulated plants have routine inspections to verify what the companies do on an everyday basis. Separate from these routine inspections, USDA also performs food safety assessments which can take days or weeks to complete. Companies under USDA jurisdiction should do their own food safety inspection to prepare for these FSIS audits. FDA regulated plants may go months or years between inspections. These facilities should have third party audits such as SQF or other audits. 

GFSI schemes have taken hold in the US and around the world. The popular one in the U.S. is SQF. Companies that meet SQF standards should have no problem meeting new FDA FSMA regulations.